← All articles Premium Listings

A Duplicate Google Profile Splits a Fireplace Store's Reviews

A fireplace store should have one Google Business Profile for each showroom. Our audits keep finding stores with two, or with a profile that still carries a name or an address the store left behind. Of the 73 dealer audits we ran from July through October this year, 8 recorded at least one of these problems. Here is what each one looks like, what Google's own rules say and how to fix it without losing the reviews.

What we counted

We went back through the 73 digital presence audits we wrote for hearth, patio and outdoor living dealers between July and October 2026. Then we counted the audits that recorded each problem. This post describes the patterns and leaves the stores out.

Three stores had two of these at once, so the 11 findings came from 8 stores. These are only the cases the audits wrote down. The early audits did not check every directory, so a store that came up clean may still have one of these problems. Treat 8 in 73 as a floor.

How a second profile gets made

The audits turned up three ways it happens.

Two profiles split the reviews

Reviews belong to the profile they were left on. When a store has two profiles, its reviews are split between them, and a shopper usually sees only one.

The ownership change shows how much that costs. Nearly all of that store's Google reviews sat on the profile under the former name. The profile under the current name had 2. In a Google Maps search for a fireplace store near that town, the old profile came up. The current one did not come up for a fireplace search or a hot tub search.

Google's rules are direct about this. Its Business Profile guidelines say "There should only be one profile per business" and that a business should not create more than one profile for each location, in one account or several. Its help page on duplicates adds a detail every owner should know. If Google decides a profile is a duplicate, that profile stops showing on Google Search and Maps. Google picks which one. It may not be yours.

Old names and old addresses send people to the wrong place

The name on a profile should be the name on the sign. Google's guidelines say the name should reflect the business's real-world name and that adding unnecessary information to it is not permitted. That rules out town names, slogans and product lists in the name field. One audit found a profile name with a second version of the store name and a location label added in parentheses.

A full rename is stricter than most owners expect. Google allows a simple edit for a minor change, where the proper nouns and services in the name stay the same and the category does not change. A bigger change counts as a new business. The old profile has to be marked closed and a new profile created under the new name. Google's help page on reopening says to contact Google if you want the reviews moved to the new profile.

Addresses linger longer than names. In our audits, old addresses and old names were still on BBB, Birdeye, Nextdoor, Yelp and manufacturer dealer locators. One store's own website gave the address it had moved out of years earlier on more than half its pages. Another store's website said one of its showrooms was moving and sent visitors to its other locations, but the Google profile for that showroom was still live, not marked closed, with an empty hours field. Each one can hand a shopper, a map app or an AI assistant the wrong address. Our post on local SEO for hearth dealers covers why consistent listings matter for ranking.

How to fix a duplicate without losing the reviews

  1. Find every profile. Search Google Maps for the store name, any former name, the phone number and every street address the store has used. Search "fireplace store" in the towns around you too. Note who manages each one and how many reviews it holds.
  2. Get access before you change anything. If the previous owners still hold a profile, Google says they have to add you as an owner and transfer it to you. If someone else holds a verified profile for your business, you can request ownership through Google. The current owner has 3 days to respond.
  3. Make the two profiles match. Google says that for a merge to work, "the profiles must represent the same business and should have the same info." Put the same name, address, phone number and category on both.
  4. Save your review replies. Google says that when two profiles are merged, their reviews are combined, but replies to reviews may be lost. Copy the replies you want to keep.
  5. Report the extra profile as a duplicate. In Google Maps, open the profile you do not want, choose Suggest an edit, then Place closed or not here, then Duplicate of another place. Google reviews every merge request, and changes can take time to show.
  6. Do not delete the profile that holds the reviews. Google warns that removing a profile from your account removes all of its content. A profile with years of reviews should be merged, not removed.

Handle a rename, a move or a closed location on the right profile

Then fix the website footer, Yelp, BBB, Houzz, Nextdoor, Facebook and every dealer locator you appear on. AI assistants build their answers from the same listings, which is part of what our post on GEO for hearth dealers covers.

Three checks any store can run this week

  1. Search Google Maps for your phone number. More than one result means more than one profile.
  2. Search for any name the store used to have. If a profile comes up, find out who manages it and how many reviews it holds.
  3. Look yourself up on each brand's dealer locator.

If your store is not showing up where it should, our post on why a fireplace store does not show up on Google covers the other common causes. Our post on premium listings for fireplace dealers covers keeping the directories in line once the profiles are fixed. If you would like us to look, send us the store name, any former names and every address the store has used. We will send back every profile and listing we find.

Sources

Read next

More for hearth and patio dealers

Next step

Talk it through with an agency that does this all day.

We will look at your market and tell you what we would actually do with your budget. No charge and no obligation.

Text us

Send a message and we will text you back.