Dealers tend to picture a web lead as someone at a desk in the middle of the afternoon. We wanted to know how often that is true, so we checked the latest 350 web form leads from the dealer sites we manage. Of those, 160 arrived while the store was closed. That is 46 percent. Here is when they came in, how long they waited for an answer and what a showroom can do about it.
What we counted
We took the latest 350 web form leads combined from the dealer websites we manage and report on. They come from seven showrooms in four states that sell fireplaces and stoves, patio furniture, stone and outdoor living. Test submissions were removed first, including our own.
Then we checked each form's time stamp against the hours that store posts on its own website. A form counts as after hours if it arrived before the showroom opened, after it closed or on a day it does not open at all. Every store in the set is on Eastern time. The time stamps are stored in UTC, so each one was converted with daylight saving time applied.
Phone calls are not in this count. They come through call tracking with their own records. We have not run the same check on them yet. Everything below is about web forms.
Nearly half arrived while the store was closed
Of the 350 forms, 160 came in outside posted hours. That is 46 percent. Here is how they split.
- Weekday evenings: 67 forms arrived after closing time, Monday through Friday.
- Weekday mornings: 29 arrived before the doors opened.
- Saturdays: 27 arrived outside Saturday hours, including at the stores that are closed all day Saturday.
- Sundays: 37 arrived on a Sunday. None of these stores opens on Sunday.
The share held up when we looked at it a few other ways. Some people send more than one form. Counting people instead of forms, 323 people reached out, and 150 of them sent their first form while the store was closed. That is also 46 percent.
One busy dealer supplied about two thirds of the forms, so we checked each dealer on its own as well. Every one of them was above 40 percent.
Early closing times account for much of it
Our first pass at this used one rule for every store: open Monday through Saturday, 9 to 6. That version found 136 forms after hours, or 39 percent. Using each store's real posted hours raised it to 46.
The difference is the late afternoon. Five of the seven showrooms close at 4:30 or earlier on weekdays. Three are closed on Saturday. Many shoppers get home from work after the showroom has locked up. A form sent at 5:15 waits until morning just like one sent at midnight.
Weekday evenings were the largest group, at 67 forms. Of those, 46 came in after 6 p.m. The other 21 arrived between the store's closing time and 6 p.m., when a lot of people would assume a store is still open.
The typical wait lasts most of a night
For each after-hours form we measured the time until that store next opened. The median was about 13 hours. Of the 160, 93 waited more than 12 hours. Of those, 29 waited more than a full day. All 29 were sent on a Saturday or a Sunday.
That wait is built into the hours. Nobody did anything wrong to cause it. What the store controls is what the shopper hears while waiting and how fast someone answers once the doors open.
What to do about it
None of this means a showroom has to stay open later or answer the phone at midnight. It means the hours the store is closed need a plan.
Make overnight forms the first job of the morning
When the doors open, the forms that came in overnight are the oldest leads in the building. Work them before the phones get busy. Name one person who owns that list each morning. Give Monday extra time, because Saturday afternoon and all of Sunday land on it at once.
Send an automatic reply that says when you will answer
A form that goes into silence at 8 p.m. leaves the shopper guessing whether it worked. An automatic email or text should confirm the request arrived, give your hours and say when a person will follow up. Something like "We open at 9 tomorrow and will call you in the morning" is enough. Include the store phone number. Keep the message short and plain.
Ask the questions you would ask on the phone
The morning callback goes better when you already know the basics. A few fields do most of the work: what the project is, the town, the timing and the best time to reach them. A message box labeled "Provide as much detail as possible" and a photo upload help more than any other fields. A photo of the existing fireplace or patio answers questions that would otherwise take a second call. Keep name, phone and email required so you can always reach the person.
Offer a way to text
Some shoppers will send a text at 9 p.m. when they would never call. A "Text us" option on the site, routed to a line someone checks at opening, gives them another way in. The rule is the same as for forms. Say when you will answer, then answer at that time.
Do not promise around-the-clock service
A site that says "available 24/7" when the showroom is staffed 9 to 5 turns a normal overnight wait into a broken promise. Post your real hours near the form. Shoppers accept a wait when they were told about it up front.
Track the after-hours share
This is a number any store can watch. Our reporting dashboard lists each lead with the time it arrived, so the after-hours share can be checked month to month. Look at it when hours change for the season. Look at it before anyone schedules the ads to stop at closing time, too. In these accounts nearly half the forms arrived while the doors were locked.
Calls deserve their own check. Our post on call tracking for showroom retailers covers how calls are recorded and counted. Our post on lead generation for hearth dealers covers where these leads come from in the first place.
How we counted
- The latest 350 web form submissions, combined, from the dealer websites we manage, after test submissions were removed.
- A form is counted once, as a form. Counted as people instead, the share is the same 46 percent.
- Store hours are the ones each store posts on its own website. Holidays and one-off closures are not reflected. A form sent on a holiday counts as during hours if it fell inside normal posted hours, so if anything the after-hours share runs low.
- One dealer's form asks which of its two showrooms the shopper wants. Those forms were checked against that showroom's hours. Forms that did not say were checked against the main showroom.
- Time stamps were converted from UTC to Eastern time with daylight saving time applied.
- Phone calls, texts and chats are not included.
If you want your own number, send us a few months of form submissions with their time stamps, along with your hours. We will run the same count and send back the result.