← All articles Lead Generator

Estimated ROAS: The Two Numbers Only the Dealer Has

Dealers ask us what their advertising returns. It is a fair question, and nobody running the ads can answer it alone. The arithmetic needs two numbers that only the store has: what an average customer spends, and how many leads turn into customers. Here is how estimated return on ad spend works, where each number comes from and how to keep the result honest.

The arithmetic takes one line

Estimated revenue is leads, times close rate, times average sale. Estimated return on ad spend is that revenue divided by what the ads cost.

A worked example shows the shape. These numbers are made up for illustration. They are not a client result.

Google uses the same ratio. Its help page on target ROAS bidding works an example of $5 in sales on $1 of ad spend and calls it 500 percent. Some reports show a percentage and some show a multiple. 500 percent and 5 to 1 are the same number.

Why the ad platform cannot fill in the blanks

The ad platforms count clicks, calls and forms. They see the lead. They do not see the sale. A fireplace sale happens in the showroom, on a home visit or after a quote that takes weeks. None of that passes through Google or Meta.

Google's own help on conversion values makes the point from the other side. A value only appears in Google Ads if the advertiser assigns one. A store that puts a flat $500 on every call sees a return built on $500, whatever its customers actually spent.

That leaves two inputs, and the dealer owns both. The LocaliQ platform we run campaigns on asks for the same two numbers in its estimated ROAS report. Our own client reporting does the same. Its estimated revenue figure stays blank until the store enters both. We do not fill in a guess, because a plausible default gets read as the store's own number.

Number one: The average sale

Pull it from your point of sale or accounting system, and pull the right slice of it.

Revenue is not profit, and that matters later. For now, write down the average ticket and the period it covers.

Number two: The close rate

This is the harder one, and most stores have never measured it. The close rate is the share of leads who became customers. It is not the share of showroom visitors who buy, which is a different number and usually a higher one.

  1. Take a list of leads from a past period. Use a month that ended at least 90 days ago. Hearth purchases take time, and a lead from October can buy in January.
  2. Match the list against your sales records. Names, phone numbers and email addresses are enough for most stores. A spreadsheet works.
  3. Divide buyers by leads. That is your close rate for that period.
  4. Repeat it for a second period. If the two numbers are far apart, use the lower one until you have more months.

If you cannot match leads to sales yet, a careful estimate from whoever answers the phone is a starting point. Label it as an estimate and replace it once you have a matched number.

A shopper who calls twice is still one lead

Many reports count events. One shopper who fills in a form, calls the next day and calls again to confirm a visit can show up as three leads. Multiply three by your close rate and that one shopper becomes most of a sale on paper.

In the example above, say the 60 people produced 85 calls and forms. Multiply 85 by 25 percent by $4,000 and the estimate jumps to $85,000, about 42 to 1. Nothing changed in the store. Only the counting did. Our post on call tracking for showroom retailers covers repeat callers and minimum call length, which drive most of this gap.

Our reporting counts each person once, in the period of their first contact. That gives a lower number than an event count. It is also the number that holds up when a dealer checks it against the register.

Small changes in either number move the result a lot

Both inputs multiply, so an error in either one carries straight through. Using the same 60 leads and $2,000 of spend:

That is why we would rather start low. An estimate that turns out conservative builds trust. One that turns out inflated costs it, and it can push a budget decision the wrong way.

Turn it into profit before deciding on budget

Estimated return on ad spend is measured on sales, not margin. To find the point where the advertising pays for itself, divide one by your gross margin. At a 35 percent margin, break-even is about 2.9 to 1. Below that, the ads cost more than the profit on the sales they are credited with.

In the example, $60,000 in sales at 35 percent is $21,000 of gross profit against $2,000 of spend. The more useful question is usually which campaigns pay best. That comes down to what each lead costs, read across a whole year rather than one busy month.

An estimate should say so, and get checked twice a year

An estimate is not a measurement, and it should say so on the page. Ours reads as modeled, with the close rate and average sale printed next to the result, so anyone reading the report can see what it rests on.

Then check it. Twice a year, rerun the close rate match on a recent quarter and update the average sale. If the store tracks which customers came from which source, compare the estimate with what those customers actually bought.

Google Ads can also take real sales back. Its offline conversion import lets an advertiser send a closed sale to Google, matched to the original ad click by a click ID or by hashed customer details such as an email address. It suits form leads best, because the click ID can be saved with the form. A walk-in who saw an ad and never filled anything in will not match. For most showrooms that keeps the estimate as the main view, with imports as a check on the share of sales they can reach.

What to ask whoever runs your ads

  1. Are leads counted as people or as events? Ask for both if the report shows one.
  2. Whose average sale and close rate are in the report? If the answer is not yours, the result is not yours either.
  3. Is the result labeled as an estimate, with the two inputs shown beside it?

If you want us to run this on your own numbers, send us twelve months of ad spend and lead counts, your average sale and a close rate estimate. We will send back the arithmetic and what it is most sensitive to, whether or not it turns into a conversation about working together. Our post on lead generation for hearth dealers covers how those leads are produced in the first place. Checking last year covers how to read a fall report without letting the season do the talking.

Sources

Every store is different. The arithmetic is simple. The two numbers that go into it are the work, and they belong to you.

Read next

More for hearth and patio dealers

Next step

Talk it through with an agency that does this all day.

We will look at your market and tell you what we would actually do with your budget. No charge and no obligation.

Text us

Send a message and we will text you back.